Butterfly, a fearful mama dog who arrived at Best Friends Animal Sanctuary with four puppies, became an enthusiastic walker who enjoys meeting people. According to Best Friends Animal Society’s March 14, 2023 feature by Sarah Thornton, her change came from slow, food-paired sessions with a caregiver and from time with a confident companion dog named Dorian. The story describes one dog’s experience. It does not establish a method that works for every fearful dog, and it does not confirm where Butterfly lives or whether she has been adopted since 2023.
Who Butterfly was when she arrived
Navajo Nation animal control picked Butterfly up after she had lived outdoors. She came to Best Friends Animal Sanctuary with four young puppies. The feature describes her as fearful of people, of indoor spaces, and of leashes. She avoided touch, retreated when caregivers approached, and showed little interest in toys. Those details matter because her later progress is measured against that starting point: she was not a dog who was already comfortable and simply needed a home.
Why Dorian mattered
After her puppies were weaned, caregivers introduced Butterfly to Dorian, a dog who enjoys people and had settled well with new dog companions. The story says Butterfly relaxed around Dorian and began joining in play with other dogs. Dorian’s ease with caregivers also gave Butterfly a way to approach people on her own schedule, watching from nearby rather than being approached directly. The feature presents this as a helpful presence rather than a training technique, and it does not describe any structured dog-to-dog introduction protocol.
How caregivers built trust one session at a time
Caregiver Ramsey Schatz described the work as gradual and patient, pairing food and calm contact with small steps toward touch and a leash. The sequence the feature describes looks like this:
#1 Best Overall
- REAL BEEF FIRST: Blue Buffalo Bits dog training treats feature high-quality, real beef as the first ingredient to deliver essential nutrition and the savory beef flavor dogs crave
- EXPERT-LED NUTRITION: Designed to help your pet thrive from the inside out, Blue Buffalo all-natural dog treats are developed by a dedicated team of veterinarians and animal nutritionists for a trusted option in healthy dog snacks
- ENHANCED WITH DHA: These BLUE Bits soft dog treats are enhanced with DHA, an Omega-3 fatty acid that supports healthy cognitive development for puppies and dogs of all ages and sizes
- PERFECT FOR DOG TRAINING: Soft, tender, bite-sized training treats for dogs make repeat rewarding easy during dog training sessions without slowing or interrupting your dog’s focus
- HEALTHY SKIN & COAT: Omega 3 & 6 fatty acids from flaxseed support healthy skin and a shiny coat
- Spend short, regular time together. Schatz sat with the dogs for 15 to 30 minutes each day.
- Offer treats and gentle petting during those sessions, so calm contact became associated with food.
- Introduce the leash sound first. Before the leash touched her, Butterfly heard the sound it made.
- Clip the leash on and off briefly, pairing each step with a treat, and let the dog move away when she needed to.
- Use her dog bed as a choice point. The bed was a place where she could decide whether the leash went on, rather than a spot where she was caught.
- Add walking pressure last. Only after the leash was routine did walking with light leash pressure begin, and that step needed further practice.
The feature does not give exact treat amounts, the types of treats or leash used, or a fixed number of repetitions per step. Those details are not reported.
The reported timeline
The story offers a small number of dated or time-based markers. They are caregiver-reported observations from one dog, not a schedule to follow.
Rank #2
- Highly Palatable with natural pork liver base
- 500 treats per bag!
- Only 1.5 calories per treat
- Clean ingredients with no corn, soy or artificial flavors
- Made with natural bacon
| Stage | What the feature reports |
|---|---|
| Arrival | Four puppies; fearful of people, indoor spaces, and leashes; avoided touch and showed little interest in toys |
| After weaning | Introduced to Dorian; relaxed and joined in play with other dogs |
| Daily sessions | 15 to 30 minutes per day with treats and petting, as described by Schatz |
| Leash acceptance | About two months to become consistently comfortable with the leash being clipped on; walking with leash pressure required more practice (duration not stated) |
| At publication (March 2023) | Enthusiastic walker who enjoys meeting people and outings with volunteers; learning to load into cars; looking for a home |
What caregivers said about her
Schatz’s recollections give the clearest picture of Butterfly’s early behavior. She would watch the caregivers and take treats from them, but she would stretch out for a treat and then dart back. Schatz described how Butterfly would put herself in a corner and shut down. Clipping the leash on in that position did not mean she wanted it, Schatz said: “she just felt trapped.” Those are one caregiver’s observations, not an independent behavioral assessment.
The change Schatz described is as striking as the early fear. “She’s just such a happy dog,” Schatz says. “She’s one of those dogs who, if you’re having a bad day and you go sit in with her, she’ll make you feel better. She’s just a bright-light, sparkly energy sort of dog.”
Rank #3
- Natural dog treats made with added vitamins and minerals and no corn, wheat, or soy at only 2 calories per treat
- Keeps dogs begging for more with soft dog treats featuring real ingredients like cherries and peanut butter
- Excellent dog training treats dogs can enjoy on the trail, or on any adventure, while encouraging bonding
- Chewy treats crafted in the USA using the Earth’s best ingredients
- Choose your adventure with other Zuke’s treats for dogs like Lil’ Links, Puppy Naturals, and Hip and Joint
What the story does and does not establish
- It documents Butterfly’s history, the routine her caregivers followed, and the timeline Schatz reported in 2023.
- It shows that her progress was tied to choice: she could move away, and the leash was introduced in steps rather than forced.
- It does not report a controlled study, a success rate, or guidance from a veterinary behaviorist or other standards body.
- It does not say whether her comfort held up after March 2023, where she lives now, or whether she has been adopted.
- It does not identify a leash, a treat brand, or any product, so nothing in the story should be read as a product recommendation.
For a dog with a similar history, the useful lesson from Butterfly’s story is the pattern rather than the timeline: short, predictable sessions, food paired with calm contact, a retreat option, and no step forward until the dog is ready. Advice on handling a specific dog’s fear, particularly if it includes aggression or self-harm, should come from a veterinarian or qualified behavior professional.
Quick Recap
Rank #4
- SHIPMENT CONTAINS: 2-pound bag (32 oz) of small bite-sized dog training treats in a resealable pouch
- PREMIUM INGREDIENTS: American chicken is the #1 ingredient, perfect for rewarding your dog during training sessions
- NO FILLERS: No added corn, soy or wheat; No added colors or artificial flavors for a wholesome treat option
- TRAINING SIZE: Small treats ideal for bite-sized rewards during training, reinforcing positive behavior without overfeeding
- PREVIOUSLY WAG: Previously Wag, now Amazon Basics. Packaging may vary but item and quality remain the same
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
