Cats.com rated Lotus cat food 7.8/10 (47/60, or B+) in a review last updated May 6, 2026. The review’s strongest marks were for ingredient quality and recall history; its weakest was price. Lotus offers wet stews and pâtés as well as oven-baked dry food, but the three recipes Cats.com assessed differ substantially in ingredients and estimated nutrient profiles. The score is Cats.com’s editorial judgment—not a certification or veterinary endorsement—and is best weighed against your cat’s preferences and your budget.
How Cats.com rated Lotus
Cats.com’s overall rating was 7.8/10, also shown as 47/60 and a B+. Its category scores were:
| Category | Cats.com score |
|---|---|
| Species-appropriateness | 8/10 |
| Ingredient quality | 9/10 |
| Product variety | 8/10 |
| Price | 4/10 |
| Customer experience | 8/10 |
| Recall history | 10/10 |
The review, written by Liz Coleman, says Cats.com examined sourcing, manufacturing, and recall history, then ordered two wet foods and one dry food for an in-home assessment. It considered nutrient content, ingredients, smell, texture, and how appealing the foods were to cats. Cats.com’s methodology explains that ratings combine nutritional and practical factors and involve judgment: “Ratings are subject to interpretation and may change over time.” Read Cats.com’s rating methodology.
For the full product-specific assessment and its review details, see Cats.com’s Lotus cat food review.
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problems2Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minute3Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errors#1 Best Overall
- Each can is hand packed in California, USA
- Made without grains, a common allergy trigger for cats
- Taurine is added to support normal vision, digestion, heart muscle function, and to maintain a healthy immune system
- This wholesome cat food is formulated with omega fatty acids to promote healthy skin and a soft coat
- Made with high-quality animal proteins plus vitamins and minerals, and vitamin E to support a strong immune system
What kinds of Lotus cat food does the review cover?
Cats.com describes a range of formats rather than a single type of food: wet recipes, dry food, raw recipes, and raw toppers. Its review identifies six “Just Juicy” canned stews with shredded meat in broth, seven canned pâté recipes, and four grain-free oven-baked dry recipes. These formats have different textures and ingredient compositions, so a finding about one recipe should not be assumed to apply to the whole range.
Where the reviewed foods are made
According to Cats.com, Lotus dry food is baked in a Canadian bakery, while wet food is made in small batches at the company-owned micro-cannery in California. The review says ingredients are primarily sourced from the United States and Canada. It lists green-lipped mussel, venison, lamb, and lamb meal from New Zealand, ground rabbit from Italy, and vitamins and minerals from Europe, except biotin, which it says comes from India.
Rank #2
- HIGH PROTEIN, NUTRIENT DENSE, MOISTURE RICH: Featuring free-range, grass-fed meats, cage-free poultry, wild-caught seafoods, and New Zealand Green Mussels, this grain-free pate style cat food delivers premium nutrition with a mouth-watering taste for all cats and life stages. This moisture rich, chunky-loaf canned cat food uniquely support cat hydration.
- GRAIN FREE, NUTRIENT RICH: Blend of premium raw ingredients providing a natural nutrient rich food to meet the needs for both a healthy indoor or outdoor cat with added vitamins and minerals. Perfect for all life stages, from kittens to senior and adult cats. No added grains, potatoes, or peas provides cats digestive support and is ideal for managing weight, allergies, and promoting overall health. This formula is free from fillers and gums commonly found in other wet cat food.
- SUPERFOODS for DIGESTION, JOINT, SKIN, and COAT HEALTH: Z-Boost superfood inclusions promote heart health and general wellness. Highly palatable and delicious cold-washed green tripe is a natural source of enzymes and probiotics for improved digestion. New Zealand Green Mussels contain chondroitin, glucosamine, and omega-3 for joint health and enhanced skin and coat. Organic Kelp is a natural source of minerals and antioxidants known to improve metabolism, reduce inflammation and protect the heart and brain.
- ALL LIFE STAGES & ALL BREEDS: Formulated for kitten, adult, and senior cats – ZIWI’s holistic approach is for all life stages, focused on delivering peak nutrition for your cat’s health and wellbeing. Perfectly fed as a complete meal or topper for a nutritional boost; optimized for both indoor and outdoor cats.
- ETHICAL NEW ZEALAND INGREDIENTS: 100% free-range, grass-fed meats, cage-free poultry, and wild-caught seafoods, all sourced from New Zealand farms and pristine oceans. Raised without added hormones, antibiotics, or growth promotants, these all-natural ingredients provide a taste of life in New Zealand.
How the three reviewed recipes compare
The review’s examples illustrate why it helps to compare a specific recipe and format rather than rely on the brand score alone. The guaranteed analyses below are label figures reported by Cats.com. Calorie and dry-matter carbohydrate estimates are calculated values from the review; Cats.com warns its automatically calculated nutrient charts may not reflect typical nutrient values, and chart figures can differ from numbers in the article text.
| Recipe | Ingredients and guaranteed analysis | Cats.com estimates | Tradeoffs noted in the review |
|---|---|---|---|
| Just Juicy Venison Stew, canned | Venison is first; the review says it contains 95% meat and broth. Crude protein 12%, crude fat 2%, crude fiber 0.5%, moisture 82%, ash 2.3%. | 84.1 calories per 2.5-ounce can; 6.67% carbohydrate on a dry-matter basis. | Single animal-protein source and high moisture, but includes potato starch, sunflower oil, and carrots. Cats.com flags the high price. Venison is a less common protein option, not a guaranteed answer to an allergy or sensitivity. |
| Just Juicy Pork Stew, canned | Pork is first. Crude protein 12%, crude fat 2%, crude fiber 1%, moisture 80%, ash 2.34%. | About 62.8 calories per 2.5-ounce can; 13.3% carbohydrate on a dry-matter basis. | Single-protein and moisture-rich, but includes potato starch, carrots, olive oil, and sunflower oil; the review calls out starch. |
| Oven-Baked Duck Recipe, dry | Duck and duck meal lead the ingredient list; pork liver is also included. Crude protein 34%, crude fat 15%, crude fiber 5.25%, moisture 10%, ash 6.5%. | 417.7 calories per cup; 32.5% carbohydrate on a dry-matter basis. | Includes peas, pea fiber, tapioca, sweet potato, and other plant ingredients. Cats.com describes it as moderate in protein, low in fat, and high in carbohydrates, with greater energy density than the wet stews. |
The estimates above are recipe-specific figures in Cats.com’s review, not guarantees of typical nutrient content. The duck dry food’s carbohydrate estimate should not be generalized to Lotus’s wet recipes or every food in the range.
Rank #3
Is Lotus cat food worth the price?
Price was Cats.com’s lowest-scoring category, at 4/10. The review gives a dated illustration rather than a current quote: using its stated $2.59 per 2.5-ounce can, its example of four cans of Just Juicy Pork per day for a 10-pound cat came to $10.36 a day. The review estimated its dry-food example at about $3.30 per day. Those figures reflect the prices and feeding example in the article; they are not current prices or a feeding recommendation for every cat.
To assess your likely cost, check the current package directions and retailer price, then account for your cat’s individual calorie needs. A daily can count from an example is not a substitute for adjusting portions to the actual food label and your cat.
Rank #4
- The Chicken Lounge Variety Pack includes three Weruva canned paté cat food recipes cage free chicken and wild caught tuna puréed into a creamy pate, 3oz Can, Pack of 12
- Pate by Weruva is Creamy McDreamy. All natural ingredients gently puréed for pate done right
- All natural. Gluten and carrageenan free. No wheat, corn, soy, artificial colors or preservatives
- Supports a healthy urinary tract. Low in phosphorus, magnesium, and ash, with proper hydration levels
- Safely produced in facilities under the strictest BRCGS Global Standards for Human Foods
What does the review say about recalls and customer feedback?
Cats.com reports that Lotus had never been recalled as of April 2026. That is a time-bounded status reported by the review, not a guarantee about future recalls or a promise of safety.
The review describes customer feedback as mostly positive about ingredients and palatability, while also noting reports of inconsistent batches, cans with excess water or few shreds, partially filled cans, and high prices. These are customer anecdotes; the review does not establish how frequently such problems occur or measure a defect rate.
Best Value
- NUTRIENT RICH CAT FOOD – Real chicken is the first ingredient, giving your cat the nutrition they needs and the taste they crave
- GRAIN FREE CAT FOOD – Your cat is a carnivore, feed them like one with high protein ingredients and no grains or carbohydrates
- REAL CHICKEN CAT FOOD – Each protein packed meal includes nutrient dense organ meat and shredded chicken in a luscious broth
- HIGH MOISTURE, LOW CALORIE CAT FOOD – Count on the high moisture content of each can of After Dark to give your cat the supplemental water they need
- BALANCED MEAL FOR ALL LIFE STAGES – From kitten to grown cat, your feline friend will benefit from the nutritional balance of Tiki Cat After Dark
What to check before choosing a Lotus recipe
- Format and texture: Decide whether your cat will eat a shredded stew, pâté, or dry food; the formats are not interchangeable in texture or composition.
- Recipe ingredients: Check the current label for the named animal proteins and other ingredients. A single named protein in a recipe does not establish that it will suit a cat with a suspected allergy or medical condition.
- Calories and portions: Use current package directions as a starting point and consider your cat’s individual calorie needs. Review estimates may not match typical nutrient values.
- Total cost: Compare current retailer prices using the amount your cat would actually eat, rather than relying on the review’s historical example.
- Availability and formulation: Confirm the recipe and package details at the retailer, since availability and product information can change.
Cats.com mentions Hound & Gatos and Weruva as lower-cost comparisons, but its review does not establish a direct current recipe-to-recipe nutrient comparison. A price comparison alone does not show that foods are nutritionally equivalent.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
