Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
The Nova Scotia Duck Tolling Retriever, or Toller, is typically the smaller, more work-focused choice; the Golden Retriever is larger and is commonly described as social, adaptable, and eager to please. Neither is a low-maintenance dog: both need daily activity, consistent training, and regular brushing. The better fit depends on how much time your household can devote to exercise and engagement—and on the temperament of the individual dog.
At a glance: how the breeds compare
| Factor | Nova Scotia Duck Tolling Retriever | Golden Retriever |
|---|---|---|
| Typical size | Medium-sized and the smallest AKC retriever. The AKC lists an ideal height of 18–19 inches; the U.S. club standard gives 18–21 inches for males and 17–20 inches for females. | Medium to large. The AKC says most weigh 55–75 pounds and stand around 23–24 inches. |
| General temperament | Intelligent, alert, affectionate with family, and ready for action. Some may be reserved in unfamiliar situations. | Generally friendly, affectionate, loyal, and socially adaptable; the AKC standard describes the temperament as “Friendly, reliable, trustworthy.” |
| Training tendency | Intelligent and willing, but may be both stubborn and sensitive. Short, productive, reward-based sessions can help. | Often eager to please and relatively easy to train. Consistency and early socialization still matter. |
| Activity | High-energy working dog that needs daily exercise and purposeful outlets. | Active sporting dog that needs daily exercise; many enjoy running, hiking, swimming, and fetch. |
| Coat care | Water-repellent double coat with seasonal shedding. Brush weekly, often daily during shedding season. | Medium-length double coat that sheds year-round and more heavily seasonally. Brush once or twice weekly, more during heavy shedding. |
| Typical lifespan cited | 12–14 years, according to the AKC breed page. | 10–12 years, according to AKC Golden Retriever guidance. |
Sources: AKC Toller breed information, AKC Golden Retriever guidance, Nova Scotia Duck Tolling Retriever Club (USA) breed standard, and the AKC Breed Temperament Guide, September 2025.
Temperament: focused worker or adaptable companion?
Nova Scotia Duck Tolling Retriever
The Toller was developed to toll, lure, and retrieve waterfowl. In its historical work, the dog moved along the shoreline to attract ducks toward the hunter, then retrieved downed birds. That background helps explain the breed’s retrieving drive and affinity for water, but it does not mean every pet Toller will show the same intensity or ability.
The AKC describes Tollers as intelligent and alert, affectionate, and potentially reserved without being shy. The Canadian breed club also notes that some may be reserved with strangers and emphasizes early socialization. A high-pitched excitement vocalization, sometimes called the “Toller scream,” occurs in some dogs; it is not a behavior to expect from every Toller.
#1 Best Overall
- REAL BEEF FIRST: Blue Buffalo Bits dog training treats feature high-quality, real beef as the first ingredient to deliver essential nutrition and the savory beef flavor dogs crave
- EXPERT-LED NUTRITION: Designed to help your pet thrive from the inside out, Blue Buffalo all-natural dog treats are developed by a dedicated team of veterinarians and animal nutritionists for a trusted option in healthy dog snacks
- ENHANCED WITH DHA: These BLUE Bits soft dog treats are enhanced with DHA, an Omega-3 fatty acid that supports healthy cognitive development for puppies and dogs of all ages and sizes
- PERFECT FOR DOG TRAINING: Soft, tender, bite-sized training treats for dogs make repeat rewarding easy during dog training sessions without slowing or interrupting your dog’s focus
- HEALTHY SKIN & COAT: Omega 3 & 6 fatty acids from flaxseed support healthy skin and a shiny coat
Golden Retriever
Goldens are generally described as friendly, affectionate, loyal, and adaptable. The AKC’s September 2025 temperament guide uses the standard wording “Friendly, reliable, trustworthy.” Those descriptions are breed tendencies, not a promise about any particular dog: socialization, experience, health, and individual temperament all matter.
Which breed is easier to train?
There is no useful basis for calling one breed categorically smarter. The practical difference is that AKC guidance describes Goldens as relatively easy to train because they are intelligent and eager to please, while it describes Tollers as a blend of “stubborn and soft.” That combination can call for patient, measured training: a Toller may resist pressure while also being sensitive to harsh correction.
For either breed, use humane, reward-based methods and keep sessions consistent. Short, purposeful sessions may suit a Toller well; a Golden’s willingness to work with its handler can make training feel more straightforward, but it does not replace practice. Early socialization helps both breeds learn to handle people, places, and everyday situations calmly.
Rank #2
- Highly Palatable with natural pork liver base
- 500 treats per bag!
- Only 1.5 calories per treat
- Clean ingredients with no corn, soy or artificial flavors
- Made with natural bacon
Exercise and daily engagement
What a Toller needs
A Toller is a high-energy working dog, so a household looking for a mostly sedentary companion may find its need for activity and engagement demanding. Exercise is more than a quick outing: provide regular physical activity along with training, retrieving, or another purposeful task. The breed club lists field work, obedience, agility, dock diving, and tracking among activities Tollers can do.
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minute2Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problems3Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesWhat a Golden needs
Goldens are active sporting dogs too, and they need daily exercise. Running, hiking, swimming, and fetch are activities many enjoy, according to the AKC. Their generally adaptable reputation should not be mistaken for low exercise needs.
Choose based on the routine you can sustain, not on the assumption that one breed will be content with little to do. The amount and type of activity an individual dog needs can vary.
Rank #3
- Natural dog treats made with added vitamins and minerals and no corn, wheat, or soy at only 2 calories per treat
- Keeps dogs begging for more with soft dog treats featuring real ingredients like cherries and peanut butter
- Excellent dog training treats dogs can enjoy on the trail, or on any adventure, while encouraging bonding
- Chewy treats crafted in the USA using the Earth’s best ingredients
- Choose your adventure with other Zuke’s treats for dogs like Lil’ Links, Puppy Naturals, and Hip and Joint
Shedding and coat care
Both breeds have double coats and shed, with heavier seasonal shedding. A Toller’s water-repellent coat generally needs weekly brushing and often daily brushing during shedding season. Keep it natural rather than relying on extensive trimming; the AKC also recommends regular nail trimming.
A Golden’s medium-length double coat sheds throughout the year and more heavily in seasonal periods. The AKC recommends brushing once or twice a week, increasing the frequency when shedding is heavy. Either breed will leave hair around the home, so regular grooming belongs in the ownership plan.
Quick wins for a faster PC:
Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Health and responsible selection
The AKC lists a typical lifespan of 12–14 years for Tollers and 10–12 years for Goldens. These are breed-page figures, not a prediction for an individual dog. The available sources do not establish comparable disease-prevalence statistics for the two breeds, so they should not be used to rank overall health.
Rank #4
- SHIPMENT CONTAINS: 2-pound bag (32 oz) of small bite-sized dog training treats in a resealable pouch
- PREMIUM INGREDIENTS: American chicken is the #1 ingredient, perfect for rewarding your dog during training sessions
- NO FILLERS: No added corn, soy or wheat; No added colors or artificial flavors for a wholesome treat option
- TRAINING SIZE: Small treats ideal for bite-sized rewards during training, reinforcing positive behavior without overfeeding
- PREVIOUSLY WAG: Previously Wag, now Amazon Basics. Packaging may vary but item and quality remain the same
For Tollers, the AKC page identifies parent-club recommended screening that includes hip, cardiac, and ophthalmologist evaluations, along with specified DNA tests; it also mentions Addison’s disease and autoimmune-related issues. Confirm the current testing recommendations with the parent club and ask a breeder for documentation relevant to the puppy’s parents. For a Golden, consult the relevant Golden Retriever club and your veterinarian about current screening guidance.
Before choosing either breed, meet adult dogs when possible and ask breeders about the temperament and health of their dogs. Breed descriptions can help set expectations, but they cannot tell you exactly how an individual dog will behave in your home.
Quick Recap
Which breed is the better fit?
- Consider a Toller if you want a smaller retriever and can make daily exercise, training, and purposeful engagement part of your routine. Be prepared for a dog that may be reserved in new situations and may need thoughtful socialization.
- Consider a Golden if you prefer a larger dog commonly described as social and eager to please, and can still provide daily exercise, consistent training, and regular coat care.
- Pause and reassess if you need a low-activity dog, cannot accommodate shedding, or are choosing based only on a breed’s reputation. Meet the individual dog and consider whether its needs fit your household.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
