Pet adoption can be harder than it needs to be when lengthy steps delay meetings, shelter hours do not match community schedules, or adopters lack clear information about an animal. In the United States, 4.2 million shelter and rescue animals were adopted in 2025, but the process still presents challenges for both prospective adopters and the organizations placing animals. Research links multiple adoption barriers with lower organization-level adoption rates; practical improvements include reviewing approval steps, offering useful animal information, and making decisions through fair, individualized conversations.
What adoption looks like in the United States
Shelter Animals Count reported 4.2 million U.S. shelter and rescue adoptions in 2025: 2.2 million cats and 2 million dogs. That was 1% more than in 2024. Its national adoption-rate measures were 57% for dogs and 63% for cats. The report defines these rates as adoptions relative to total intakes, so they should not be confused with rates calculated using only animals available for adoption. The figures are national estimates based on reported shelter and rescue data and may vary by state. Shelter Animals Count’s 2025 Annual Data Report
| # | Preview | Product | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
|
My Someone: A Pet Adoption Story | $13.25 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 |
|
FairyTails Pet Adoptions: Spooky Activity Book | $13.99 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 |
|
Can I Be Your Dog? | $11.48 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 |
|
Hey Little Rockabye: A Lullaby for Pet Adoption | $10.48 | Buy on Amazon |
| 5 |
|
Pet Adoption Agreement Forms Book: Cat / Dog Adoption Contract Form | 50 Agreement Forms | $9.99 | Buy on Amazon |
Why the adoption process can become a barrier
For a prospective adopter, friction can arise before they ever meet an animal: an application may be required first, a shelter may not permit same-day adoption, or verification, landlord checks, or home visits may add steps. Some safeguards can serve legitimate purposes, but requiring several steps in every case can make a process less accessible without necessarily improving the match.
Shelter Animals Count analyzed its May 2025 survey of 347 organizations alongside those organizations’ full-year 2024 data. Forty percent reported no adoption barriers, 24% reported one, 18% reported two, and 19% reported three or more. Examples included requiring an application before meeting an animal, not allowing same-day adoptions, home visits or landlord checks, and verification requirements. Organizations reporting three or more barriers had adoption rates about seven percentage points lower than organizations reporting none. Organizations reporting one or two barriers performed similarly to those reporting none.
Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
#1 Best Overall
The analysis controlled for organization type, region, intake size, species mix, and share of outcomes transferred, and the finding held across two model specifications. Even so, these are organization-level associations, not proof that a particular rule caused a lower rate or that removing it would produce a specific improvement. Shelter Animals Count’s analysis of adoption barriers and outcomes
Which process changes have evidence behind them?
Review steps between interest and meeting an animal
Map what a person must do from first inquiry to meeting a pet and from meeting to adoption. Ask whether each application, check, or verification is needed for every case, whether it can happen at the right point in the process, and whether staff can complete it promptly. The evidence supports reviewing accumulated barriers; it does not identify a single step whose removal is guaranteed to improve outcomes.
Consider same-day adoption when appropriate
In Shelter Animals Count’s analysis, organizations that allowed same-day adoptions—either consistently or case by case—had a 66% adoption rate, compared with 57% among organizations that never allowed them. This comparison is an association, not a promise of a nine-point gain for a shelter that changes its policy. A shelter can consider same-day placement when its staffing, local requirements, animal’s needs, and adopter conversation allow it.
Compare opening hours with community demand
The analysis found that Saturday adoption activity was about 61% higher than an average weekday. That pattern gives shelters a reason to examine when prospective adopters can visit, alongside local traffic, staffing, and outcomes. It does not establish that extending Saturday hours will deliver the same increase everywhere.
Keep safeguards while making access fair
There is no single screening model used by all shelters. The ASPCA says programs range “from no screening (any animal is available to anyone) to the use of rigid guidelines to screen potential adopters.” Its guidance describes conversation-based adoption as a middle ground: staff discuss the animal and the person’s circumstances, using judgment rather than relying only on rigid rules.
Accessible processes still need to protect animals and treat people fairly. The ASPCA advises that policies should not discriminate against or disparately affect protected or underserved groups. It also supports prompt adoption or transfer for suitable animals after appropriate medical and behavioral evaluation. For a shelter, this means evaluating an adopter’s ability to meet a particular animal’s needs through a thoughtful conversation, while avoiding blanket rules that unnecessarily exclude people.
Rank #3
ASPCA Position Statement on Responsibilities of Animal Shelters
Give adopters clear information to make a good match
Prospective adopters need more than a photograph or a quick introduction. They can ask shelter staff or foster caregivers about health, behavior, daily routine, and prior history where it is known. A useful answer distinguishes documented facts from what remains uncertain, especially when an animal’s life before entering the shelter is incomplete.
Quick wins for a faster PC:
Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitchesFind Drivers →Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →An ASPCA survey of nearly 1,500 adopters at five U.S. animal-welfare organizations, conducted from January through May 2011, found that appearance, social behavior with the adopter, and playfulness ranked among leading reasons for choosing a pet. More than 27% of dog adopters cited appearance as their single most important reason; more than 26% of cat adopters cited behavior with people. Roughly 80% said staff or volunteer information was an important source. Nearly 90% considered health information important, roughly 80% considered behavior information important, and roughly 60% considered the animal’s life before the shelter important.
Rank #4
These reported preferences come from a small, older, five-shelter survey; they are not current national estimates or proof that a particular matching practice raises adoption rates. They do underline why a conversation and accurate information matter. Ask yourself, “Why did you choose this pet?” and consider whether the animal’s needs and temperament fit your household and capacity. ASPCA, “Why Did You Choose Your Pet?” (April 18, 2012)
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Address barriers beyond the shelter visit
Adoption is only one part of keeping pets and people together. The ASPCA identifies access to pet-friendly housing, affordable veterinary care, and behavioral support as areas where community assistance can help families keep pets. Shelter capacity can also be strained by animals with medical or behavioral challenges that require more intensive resources. These are important conditions affecting pet ownership and retention, not measured explanations for why every individual prospective adopter decides against adoption.
Families who are unsure they can manage a particular cost or challenge can ask local shelters or community organizations whether support is available. For shelters, connecting families with housing assistance, veterinary resources, or behavioral help can complement fair adoption processes and reduce pressure on already busy facilities.
“Keeping pets in loving homes, removing barriers to adoption and helping lost pets return to their families are some of the most effective ways to support animals and reduce pressure on shelters that are already operating at or beyond capacity.” — Matt Bershadker, ASPCA president and CEO. ASPCA U.S. Animal Shelter Statistics
How to compare adoption processes as an adopter
Policies vary by organization, so ask practical questions rather than assuming every shelter follows the same rules. Useful comparison points include:
- Whether you can meet an animal before completing an application or approval process.
- Whether same-day adoption is possible when the animal and circumstances are a good fit.
- Which days and hours are available for visits and adoptions.
- How clearly staff explain the animal’s medical information, behavior, and known history.
- Whether staff offer a conversation about fit and explain what support or follow-up is available.
These questions can help you understand what to expect; national organization-level findings do not rank individual shelters. To support a local organization, consider adoption, fostering, or volunteering according to your circumstances. ASPCA guidance on U.S. shelters and ways to help
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
