Hardware FixRecommendedDevice not working? Your driver may be the problemCheck updates for common hardware issues.Fix DriversThanksgiving DealsAmazon USThanksgiving week: Black Friday picks start earlyAmazon US: current deals, useful picks and tech finds.Check DealsClean PCRecommendedOne scan can reveal what keeps slowing WindowsLook for cleanup and repair opportunities.Run Scan×
Skip to the story
ANIMALSO
Breeding

Can Birds Be Pessimistic? What Starling Studies Really Show

European starlings sometimes choose poorer-outcome responses to ambiguous cues. Here is what that reveals about bird welfare—and what it cannot prove about emotion.

By Animalso Team 8 min read

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

Some links on this page are affiliate links: if you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you.

Yes, in a carefully defined behavioral sense. Some birds, especially European starlings, choose the response linked with a poorer outcome when they encounter an ambiguous cue. Scientists call that a pessimistic judgment bias. It suggests that the bird’s current state can affect how it interpret uncertain information, but it does not prove the bird feels human-like pessimism or consciously expects disaster.

The strongest avian evidence comes from controlled starling experiments that changed housing enrichment and measured responses to uncertain light signals or objects. Results differ between experiments, so a single test cannot serve as a complete readout of a bird’s emotions or welfare.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

What “pessimistic” means in bird studies

In everyday speech, pessimism is an outlook about the future. A person may believe that bad events are likely, remember disappointments, or feel gloomy. Birds cannot describe their expectations, so researchers use an operational definition based on choices.

A bird first learns that one cue predicts a better outcome and another cue predicts a poorer outcome. An intermediate cue is then presented. If the bird responds as though the poorer outcome is more likely, it is recorded as showing a pessimistic judgment bias. If it responds as though the better outcome is more likely, it is recorded as showing an optimistic bias.

Popular on Amazon
Sale
The Sibley Guide to Bird Life & Behavior
  • Used Book in Good Condition

The word bias matters. The result is a measurable shift in responding, not a direct measurement of a private feeling. The same outward choice could be influenced by attention, learning history, motivation, sensory discrimination or the way the task is designed. A judgment-bias result is therefore evidence about affective state by inference, rather than a verbal report of what a bird feels.

How a judgment-bias experiment works

  1. Train two reference cues. One stimulus is consistently associated with a favorable result, such as immediate food. A second stimulus is associated with a less favorable result, such as a delayed, smaller or absent reward, depending on the experiment.
  2. Present an ambiguous cue. The test stimulus lies between the two trained cues. In a light-duration task, for example, an intermediate flash is neither clearly the positive nor clearly the negative signal.
  3. Record the bird’s decision. The bird may choose between locations, lids or response options, or it may be asked to make a go/no-go response. Choosing the option linked to the poorer outcome is classified as pessimistic responding.
  4. Compare conditions or individuals. Researchers can compare enriched and standard housing, before-and-after changes, or birds that differ in stress-related behavior. The interpretation is strongest when the judgment-bias result agrees with independent welfare measures.

“Ambiguous” does not mean identical across studies. A pale-grey lid, an intermediate light duration and an uncertain color are different sensory problems. Task format also matters: an active-choice test requires the animal to select among alternatives, whereas a go/no-go design measures whether it responds to a stimulus at all. These differences can change the pattern of results.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

What European starling studies found

Enriched housing and intermediate light signals (2008)

In a 2008 study, captive European starlings lived in either larger, enriched cages or less enriched housing. The birds were trained with light stimuli of different durations, with one duration associated with immediate food. When shown an intermediate-duration light, starlings from the larger enriched cages were more likely to classify it as the cue associated with immediate food.

The authors interpreted that more favorable classification as greater optimism under housing conditions judged to support better welfare. The result is avian evidence that the environment can influence how a bird treats uncertainty. It does not establish that every enriched bird feels happy or that every bird in a standard cage feels pessimistic; it is a difference in the probability of a particular trained response.

Reduced enrichment and individual behavior (2010)

A 2010 starling experiment reduced enrichment and tested whether birds became more pessimistic. The group did not show a simple overall increase in pessimistic choices. That absence of a straightforward group effect is important: changing one welfare-related condition does not guarantee a uniform shift in every bird’s judgment bias.

At the individual level, however, birds that performed more repetitive somersaulting were more likely to choose the lower-reward option for the most ambiguous cue. Somersaulting was treated as a stress-related repetitive behavior, so the association connected an independent behavioral sign with pessimistic responding. It still remains an association, not proof that the repetitive behavior and the choice arose from one identifiable emotion.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

Pale-grey lids and cage-order experience

An earlier starling categorization study used lids hiding mealworms. The probability that a bird classified an ambiguous pale-grey lid as hiding a mealworm was lower in standard cages than in enriched cages. The effect depended on which cage condition the bird experienced first. This order effect shows why a result can reflect experience and learning as well as current welfare: the sequence of conditions can alter how birds categorize later cues.

Avian studies at a glance

Study Species and cue Condition or manipulation Ambiguous-cue result Important qualification
2008 European starlings; intermediate-duration light Larger enriched cages compared with less enriched housing Enriched-cage birds more often classified the intermediate light as the immediate-food cue Interpretation was greater optimism under housing judged to support better welfare; the response remains an indirect measure
2010 European starlings; trained reward cues and an ambiguous stimulus Enrichment reduced No simple overall rise in pessimism; birds with more repetitive somersaulting favored the lower-reward response for the most ambiguous cue Group averages and individual behavior did not tell the same story
Earlier categorization study European starlings; pale-grey lid concealing a mealworm Standard versus enriched cages Standard-cage birds were less likely to classify the ambiguous lid as mealworm-associated Effect depended on cage-order experience
2019 hen study Hens; judgment-bias task alongside startle testing Welfare-improving enrichment Little change in judgment bias Startle responses fell greatly, demonstrating that welfare measures can disagree

Why the evidence does not prove human-like pessimism

The test infers an internal state

A choice linked to a low reward is compatible with a pessimistic interpretation, but it is not a direct readout of consciousness. A bird could be responding to differences in stimulus salience, attention, motivation or learned categorization. Without language, there is no independent verbal confirmation of what the bird expected or felt.

Effects are small and variable across species and tasks

A 2020 meta-analysis combined 459 effect sizes from 71 studies involving 22 non-human species. Relatively better conditions generally corresponded to more optimistic responses, but the overall effects were small and heterogeneous. Task type, reinforcement design and sex moderated outcomes. In practical terms, the direction found in one experiment is not guaranteed to appear with another cue, another reward schedule or another population.

Learning can mimic a judgment bias

A 2023 bumblebee study showed that shifts in stimulus-response curves can create apparent differences in judgment bias. A curve may move because animals learn or categorize stimuli differently, even when the change cannot be uniquely assigned to an emotional state. This finding does not erase judgment-bias evidence, but it requires investigators to separate affective explanations from ordinary changes in learning and discrimination.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

Welfare indicators can disagree

The 2019 hen study is a useful warning. Enrichment greatly reduced startle responses while producing little change in judgment bias. If the judgment-bias test had been used alone, it would have missed a welfare-related change detected by another measure. Strong assessments therefore combine decision tasks with independent indicators such as startle, repetitive behavior and physiological measures.

What bees add to the comparative picture

Evidence from insects broadens the question but does not settle whether birds experience human-style pessimistic feelings. Honeybees exposed to vigorous shaking were more likely to classify ambiguous odors as predicting punishment. They also showed lower levels of hemolymph dopamine, octopamine and serotonin. These physiological changes are consistent with a stress-related state, but they do not make an insect response equivalent to a human mood.

In a 2024 active-choice bumblebee study, physically stressed bees were more likely to choose low-reward locations when shown ambiguous colors. Because the bees actively selected among options, the result complements go/no-go designs, yet it remains an inference from behavior. Cross-species consistency makes judgment bias a useful comparative tool; it does not turn the operational definition into proof of a particular subjective experience.

Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Support on Ko-Fi

What this means for pet-bird welfare

For a companion-bird owner, the studies support a cautious conclusion: a bird’s living conditions and recent experiences can influence how it responds to uncertainty. They do not provide a home test for diagnosing pessimism, depression or a specific emotional state.

What’s actually slowing this PC down?

Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

Do not infer welfare from one behavior or one choice. A more responsible assessment looks for patterns and checks several kinds of evidence:

  • Repetitive behavior: persistent, abnormal repetition may be relevant, as the starling somersaulting association illustrates, but it must be interpreted in context.
  • Startle and recovery: changes in startle responses can reveal effects that a judgment-bias task misses, as in the enriched-hen study.
  • Behavioral engagement: willingness to explore, forage or interact can add context, provided changes are compared with the individual bird’s normal baseline.
  • Physical and physiological signs: changes in condition or other health indicators require appropriate professional assessment rather than an emotional label.

Enrichment should not be treated as a guaranteed way to make every bird “optimistic.” In the starling work, enrichment effects were not uniform, and the order in which conditions were experienced mattered. Offer suitable opportunities for species-typical activity, monitor the bird over time and seek an avian veterinarian or qualified behavior professional when behavior changes persist or are accompanied by signs of illness.

How to judge a claim that a bird is pessimistic

When reading a study or a headline, ask these questions:

  • Which species was tested? Direct avian evidence summarized here comes mainly from European starlings, with a separate hen study. It should not automatically be generalized to parrots, finches or all birds.
  • What were the positive and negative cues? The reward arrangement determines what a “pessimistic” choice means.
  • How was ambiguity created? Intermediate light duration, a pale-grey lid and an uncertain color are not interchangeable stimuli.
  • Was the task active-choice or go/no-go? These formats measure different aspects of responding.
  • What welfare manipulation was used? Enrichment, reduced enrichment and housing order can have different effects.
  • Were independent measures collected? Startle, stereotypy and physiology can support or challenge an interpretation based on judgment bias alone.
  • Were individual differences and learning considered? Group averages may conceal associations with repetitive behavior, while stimulus-response changes may reflect categorization rather than affect.

The most accurate answer

Birds can show pessimistic-like judgment biases: when an ambiguous cue falls between signals for a good and a poor outcome, some birds are more likely to choose the poor-outcome response. European starling studies link these responses to enrichment, housing experience and individual repetitive behavior, but the findings are not uniform.

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

The scientifically defensible wording is therefore “some birds show pessimistic judgment bias under some conditions,” not “birds are pessimists.” The behavior is valuable evidence about how welfare and uncertainty may interact, while its causes and subjective meaning remain open to interpretation.

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply. Prices as of November 21, 2026 12:08 pm GMT+0530.
Sponsor this story
Put your brand in front of the people reading this
Every 3 years, every 2 years, yearly or monthly; the price is at the checkout · no sales call · Above USD 3,000, or permanent? Custom request: email us or use our contact form. · Every offer, in The Den and the atlas →

animal cognitionbird behaviorbird welfareEuropean Starlingsjudgment bias

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Special offer. See more information about Outbyte and uninstall instructions. Please review EULA and Privacy policy.

More from The Den

Recommended PC Tool
Recommended PC Tool
Outdated Drivers Are Slowing You DownFree scan - exact matches
PC Slower Than It Used to Be?Free scan - under a minute

Two free Windows tools

One Free Minute Could Fix That PC

Before you go - each of these free tools takes about a minute and tackles what quietly slows a Windows PC down.

Special offer. View Outbyte info, uninstall instructions, EULA, and Privacy Policy.