Nom Nom no longer sells cat food, so you cannot order its cat recipes today. Cats.com states that “As of Feb 24 2022 Nom Nom no longer sells cat food recipes,” and keeps its review online for readers who want the history. Catster’s page, updated September 17, 2026, says the fresh cat-food recipe has been discontinued and that the company is no longer taking orders for it.
What the Cats.com review scored
The Cats.com review, written by Mallory Crusta, a NAVC-certified Pet Nutrition Coach, gives Nom Nom 6/10 overall. It expresses that as 36 out of 60 and a C+ grade on the page last updated February 11, 2026. The review rates the product across six categories:
| Category | Cats.com score |
|---|---|
| Species appropriateness | 8/10 |
| Ingredient quality | 10/10 |
| Product variety | 2/10 |
| Price | 5/10 |
| Customer experience | 6/10 |
| Recall history | 5/10 |
| Overall | 6/10 (36/60, C+) |
These are the review’s own editorial scores. They are not a nutrition certification, not population data, and not a rating of the product as it is sold now. The pattern is informative, though. The perfect ingredient score sits beside the weakest variety score, which is consistent with the review’s account that only one cat recipe was offered at the time.
The recipes the review described
Chicken Cuisine
According to Cats.com, Chicken Cuisine was the only Nom Nom cat recipe when the review was written. The review describes fresh poultry, fruits and vegetables, single-serve packets that needed refrigeration, and custom portioning. These are details of a past product line, not a guide to what the company offers now.
#1 Best Overall
- Premium cat food delivers 100 percent complete and balanced nutrition and is 100 percent made to delight
- Crafted with high-quality Fancy Feast cat food ingredients, including real ocean fish and salmon
- Provides essential vitamins for cats, plus minerals to help support feline health
- Gourmet Purina Fancy Feast cat food dry recipe baked into wonderfully crisp morsels for a crunchy texture that cats love
- Purina Fancy Feast dry food produced using healthy ingredients in Purina-owned facilities
Fish Feast and Chicken Chow-Meow
Cats.com says Fish Feast had been offered for a limited time and was no longer available when its main review was written. A separate Cats.com historical review covers Fish Feast and Chicken Chow-Meow, and its reviewer received a sample box. That is one reviewer’s report from a past period. It is not a test you can repeat, and it does not show that either recipe can be ordered today.
The 2021 recall described in the review
Cats.com reports that certain Chicken Cuisine lots produced March 8–17 were affected in 2021, after Tyson Foods recalled chicken over potential Listeria contamination. The review says no cat illnesses had been reported in its account. The lot and date details are as the review reports them. If you need to confirm whether a specific bag was affected, check the lot codes against the regulator’s recall notice rather than relying on this article or the review.
Rank #2
- CLEAN BOWLS AHEAD - Chef Bobby Flay and his cat Nacho worked with top pet nutritionists to create a menu that pairs the nutrition cats need with the flavors and textures they crave
- CHEF-APPROVED PROTEIN - We start with premium, cage-free chicken, rich in amino acids for super strong muscles
- MADE FOR PICKY EATERS - Our Chicken & Pumpkin dry cat food combines impeccably chosen ingredients with a crunchy, cat-pleasing texture for a recipe that leaves ordinary kibble in the dust
- CLAW-OPEN-THE-BAG GOOD - We infuse every bite with dehydrated bone broth for a satisfying flavor cats can’t resist
- HAPPY BELLY, HAPPY CAT - Prebiotics and probiotics support digestion and a healthy gut microbiome; pumpkin, cranberries, and other superfoods provide fiber, aid in digestion, and support overall immune health
Nom Nom’s current official pages cover dog food
The company’s current official pages describe dog food. Its FAQ covers dog recipes, dog-food retail channels and canine formulation. Its meal-formulation page says recipes are evaluated by veterinary nutritionists and a PhD science team, but it does not name a cat product. Its medical-needs help page tells dog owners to consult their veterinarian. None of this transfers to cats, so do not read dog availability or nutrition claims as cat product information.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Choosing a fresh-food replacement for your cat
Catster names Smalls as a replacement for Nom Nom. Treat that as a starting lead, not a verified recommendation. The sources available for this article do not establish whether Smalls delivers to your area, what recipes it offers, or whether those recipes are complete for your cat’s life stage. Before ordering, check:
The Tool Desk
Outbyte PC Repair FREEClear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →Outbyte Driver Updater FREEScan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Quick Recap
Best Value
- REAL SHRIMP & SALMON, IN SAVORY SAUCE: Optimeal Indoor Health wet cat food. Lean seafood proteins for less-active indoor cats. Cloud-shaped morsels in savory sauce for ideal mouthfeel and maximum palatability. Grain free, high protein taste cats love.
- COMPLETE & BALANCED, CRAFTED BY NUTRITION EXPERTS: Meets AAFCO standards for complete and balanced adult cat nutrition. Optimeal wet cat food is made with premium European ingredients and essential balanced nutrients for daily energy, health and wellbeing. Grain Free, No Carrageenan, Non-GMO, no corn, soy, wheat, artificial flavors or colors.
- INDOOR HEALTH FORMULA: Lean seafood proteins suited to the lifestyle of less-active indoor cats. Prebiotic FOS supports healthy digestion, vitamins & minerals support immune health, and Omega-3 & 6 from French salmon oil keep skin healthy and coat shiny.
- 96%+ OF PROTEIN FROM ANIMAL SOURCES: Real animal protein in every bite, no fillers, no rendered by-products, no compromises. Clean, lean high-protein nutrition crafted for less-active indoor cats. Serve as a complete meal or as a topper over dry kibble.
- SEALED FOR FRESHNESS & MOISTURE-RICH: Pouches lock in moisture and natural aromas for fresher taste every meal. Great for picky cats. Serve as a complete meal or mix over kibble to add vital hydration.
Rank #4
- Indulgent, Lickable Cat Treat: Made with real chicken, salmon, or tuna, Sheba Premium Puree Cat Treats are crafted with a creamy texture cats love
- Chef-Inspired Flavors: Sheba Premium Puree Cat Treats are made with chef-inspired flavors that are protein-rich and incredibly delicious
- Premium Recipe: These incredibly delicious grain-free cat treats are made with real meat, no corn, wheat, or soy, and no artificial flavors, although trace amounts may be present due to potential cross-contact at manufacturing site
- Single-Serve Squeezable Tube: Sheba Premium Puree Cat Treats are a soft, lickable cat treat; feed 1-2 tubes daily per 10 lbs. of cat body weight as a treat or with your cat's regular meal
- Bonding Moments: Sheba Premium Puree Cat Treats supports a strong bond between pet parents and their cats with a satisfying and savory snack
Rank #3
- Omega-Rich and High-Meat - Made with cage-free chicken and sustainably farmed King Salmon for high protein, DHA, and omega fatty acids, Feline Natural Cat Food helps maintain healthy brain and eye function, coat, and joints.
- Real and Wholesome - With green-lipped mussels, vitamins, minerals, and taurine, this chicken and king salmon dry cat food offers clean nutrition without grains, soy, wheat, corn, or artificial fillers.
- Complete and Balanced Formula - Formulated to meet AAFCO Cat Nutrient Profiles, Feline Natural cat food provides essential nutrients to support brain, skin and coat, and joint health.
- Easy to Feed - Serve this chicken and king salmon cat food as-is for a satisfying crunch, crumble over meals, or rehydrate with warm water for soft cat food for senior cats, adult cats, and kittens.
- Crafted with Care - Sourced from ethical New Zealand farms, this Feline Natural freeze-dried cat food is traceable from pasture to bag, reflecting the brand’s commitment to purity and quality.
- Delivery and cost: whether the service ships to your location, and the weekly cost after delivery fees, not only the price per bag.
- Completeness: whether the product page or label says the food is complete and balanced for cats, and which life stage it is formulated for (kitten, adult, senior, or all life stages).
- Ingredients: the full ingredient list and any added nutrients, compared against your cat’s needs.
- Storage: fresh food usually needs refrigerator or freezer space. Confirm you can store it before you commit.
- Veterinary fit: if your cat has a medical condition, is on a prescription diet, or has a weight concern, ask your veterinarian before switching.
- Transition: common veterinary guidance is to change foods gradually over about 7 to 10 days, mixing a growing share of the new food into the old.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
